Friday, July 13, 2007



Speaking of Home - A home birth sighting in the Comics page! And a great article:


Home Birth in Comic Strip Garnering More Praise than Concern
Eugene, OR (06/28/2007) E-mails praising cartoonist Jan Eliot’s storyline in “Stone Soup” about her central character’s pregnancy and home birth have been arriving daily to the Eugene, Ore. artist. The baby’s arrival with the help of a midwife is imminent in the strip. http://www.gocomics.com/stonesoup/

Many midwives and mothers are happy that this alternative method of childbirth is being examined on the comic pages. Even the one person self-described as a Portland obstetrician and fan was not overly critical about the home birth scenario.

“The doctor who wrote me is actually very supportive of midwives. He just prefers they deliver in hospitals or birth centers, believing the chances for the health of the child and mother increases,” says Eliot, who first introduced “Stone Soup” in November 1995 and is syndicated by Universal Press Syndicate.

“I expect to get opinions on both sides of this issue up until the time Joan delivers,” says Eliot. "The mail so far has been overwhelmingly supportive of the home birth. For healthy women under the care of a professional midwife, home births are certainly an option today that's chosen by many."

One fan with home birth experience told Eliot in an e-mail: “It’s great to see this safe and healthy choice get more exposure. I wish more people realized there are options besides ‘Go to the hospital and be a good little patient and do everything the nurses tell you...’”

“So many people believe that the only place a baby should be born is in the hospital, when studies show that normal, low-risk women fare better having their babies at home,” commented another fan.

Eliot plans to introduce Joan’s midwife this weekend (June 29-30). The character will have a master’s degree from Yale’s Certified Nurse Midwife program, which is one of the top programs in the country.

Eliot’s daughter in real life has had two home births, and one of Eliot’s first newspaper publishers, Jody Rohlnik of the Cottage Grove (Ore.) Sentinel, had both her children at home using the water birth method that Eliot has introduced into the storyline of the script.

Eliot has pulled out all the stops to make sure Joan’s pregnancy is portrayed as realistically as possible, including morning sickness in the car, suppers of only saltines and grapes, and the massive swollen ankles. The storyline included Val’s 13-year-old daughter Holly planning to have kids before going to college, but Val convinced the teenager of the fallacy of that plan, partly by having her view a birth DVD.

However, the storyline isn’t completely steeped in reality. Eliot created a comic-character-centered baby shower hosted by Val’s recurring book club, which includes Elly from For Better or For Worse, Connie from Zits, Cathy from Cathy, and even Alice from Dilbert, who just came for the gin.

In just a few weeks Eliot has scheduled the birth, so soon Joan will have to balance a brand new baby and her two-year-old son, Max, who doesn’t seem too excited about having to share his mama. Despite husband Wally’s sweet nature and enthusiasm, Joan worries how she will ever raise two kids, especially when one of them is the mischievous and ever-busy Max.

“Between the circus clown maternity clothes and summer heat, Joan (a.k.a. Shamu) is more than ready to be done with pregnancy,” says Eliot.


I have a soft spot for homebirthed babies, having one of them myself!

16 Comments:

At 11:14 PM , Blogger Elizabeth said...

I thought that was so cool! I had never seen homebirth even mentioned in the comics pages. The only unrealistic thing portrayed was--covering up during labor? Are you kidding? Why would you do that at home? I was the most immodest I've ever been during both births.

 
At 4:49 AM , Blogger DebD said...

This sounds lovely. I don't think I could read it because it would make me want more babies. I loved giving birth at home.

 
At 8:38 AM , Blogger elizabeth said...

cool post! there is a midwife in my church here; it is certianly a very good thing. :)

 
At 2:52 PM , Blogger Mimi said...

I had never seen homebirth even mentioned in the comics pages
Elly had one with April in For Better or for Worse, but it was unitentional (although she'd kicked it around prior). But, that's been a long time.

I agree, they were very modest in the strip, and I certainly wasn't.

Ooooh, Elizabeth - a midwife in your parish? I think that Orthodoxy is very homebirth friendly.

Deb, me too! I could have a million babies, but I don't want a million kids

 
At 5:11 PM , Blogger EC Gefroh said...

Mimi, my sister and I were both home birthed in Peru.

 
At 6:11 PM , Blogger Elizabeth said...

Yeah, there is Elly, but I don't really count that as a homebirth. Nothing they said beforehand "we're having a homebirth" about, certainly.

 
At 7:58 AM , Blogger Renee said...

If God gives me another opportunity, I intend to birth at home. My other seven births were with a midwife in a hospital, but I would love to be a home the entire time. we'll see!

 
At 8:25 AM , Blogger Liz in Seattle said...

Okay, our MATUSHKA is a midwife (she said smugly!)

Me, I'm a gimme-the-drugs kind of gal. But since I was labelled high risk, I was in the hospital anyway.

The one advantage to the hospital (other than no sleep) is that Grandma and Grandpa come over to watch the other kid, and they clean house!

 
At 8:58 AM , Blogger Unknown said...

Wow!
Didn't know you had one of the boys at home! I would've never even considered it, I was a nutcase as it was. you are way stronger than I.

 
At 11:25 AM , Blogger Vintage Papers said...

how very cool! I didn't know you had a baby at home. My parents were both born at home - but that was back in the day. I would much rather have been at home then in the old yucky hospital!
BTW - thanks for your kind words, love and support regarding my boy.
It has been hard - and I know this is just the beginning - but it is nice to know that you will keep him in your prayers. Bless you Mimi!

 
At 11:49 AM , Blogger Lauren S. said...

If I'm blessed with a next one, I would LOVE to have a home birth. I really could have done without being in the hospital for my son's birth (and probably my daughters too, but I'll never know...)

Cute comic.

 
At 1:52 PM , Blogger Bluecanopy said...

so cool...thanks for that!

 
At 10:48 AM , Blogger Suzanne said...

You need to share your story!
Wow! I am proud of you for trusting so well. I was like one of your commentors in that I didn't trust my own decisions..deciding to breast feed and later homeschool has been something that many of mine and Danny's family have had "fun" learning to accept. Still, I don't know if I'd try this at home...I worried that the train track would not be blocked with a train so that I could be sure to get to the hospital on time! Such a brave woman, I am! LOL!

 
At 10:21 PM , Blogger Fr. David said...

This comment has been removed by the author.

 
At 3:32 PM , Blogger Kitty said...

Wow! How cool! I have had 5 of my 6 births at home, plan on having #7 at home in September, and will never go back to the hospital if I don't have to. I am grateful for hospitals when it comes to emergencies and things that can't be taken care of at home, but as a low-risk Momma, I will take home birth any day!

 
At 10:52 AM , Blogger yofed said...

Taht's hilarious! I had my second baby like that, at home, in 2 hours, 9lbs 14oz! That looked so familiar!

 

Post a Comment

Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]

<< Home