Monday, October 03, 2005

So help me, I'm backseat teaching is that the term?

Cedric, in 9th Grade English, just finished Of Mice and Men by John Steinbeck. I remember reading it in school, most certainly remember the sad ending (after I asked him if he thought the ending was sad, his reply was "that's what you said at the end of the Outsiders too, Mom, are you going to ask me that at the end of every book?) Anyway, so I asked him if they talked about the title of the book.

After his blank look, I backed up and asked him about the poem. His eyes rolled in a way that confirmed that his teacher had not brought up the poem by Robert Burns

But Mousie, thou are no thy-lane,
In proving foresight may be vain:
The best laid schemes o' Mice an' Men,
Gang aft agley,
An' lea'e us nought but grief an' pain,
For promis'd joy!


(thanks to Charli for reminding me of the title "To A Mousie").

He later told me he asked the teacher about the title and she assured him it was not part of the test.

I'm awfully surprised. And, to make me feel better, I found this on the online Cliffs Notes

Fate
Life’s unpredictable nature is another subject that defines the human condition. The title of the novel is taken from the poem of Robert Burns, “To a Mouse On Turning Her Up in Her Nest with a Plow,” November, 1785. Burns wrote that “The best laid schemes o’ mice and men / Gang aft a-gley [often go astray], / And lea’v us nought but grief and pain, / For promised joy.”
Just when it appears that George and Lennie will get their farm, fate steps in. Lennie just happens to be in the barn burying his dead pup when Curley’s wife comes in. In this case, fate is given a hand by Lennie’s inability to control his strength and understand what to do. Nevertheless, often life seems unpredictable and full of overwhelming difficulties.


I guess I'm not really a backseat teacher, though, because I haven't complained to her. Just to y'all!

12 Comments:

At 3:45 PM , Blogger Mz. Pig said...

I so love that book. Alas, I have been misquoting all these years.
I say, the best laid 'plans.'
'Schemes' it is!
Kudos to you for discussing it with Cedric.

 
At 4:04 PM , Blogger Mimi said...

I remember it as "plans" too - I'm thinking there may be more than one translation.

 
At 5:50 PM , Blogger Jennifer said...

That was probably the only assigned reading from high school that I actually read, and we didn't learn anything about the poem either, BUT I'd always heard the saying, "Best laid plans of mice and men..."

 
At 7:57 PM , Anonymous Anonymous said...

Good for you for being a backseat teacher! A necessary thing to be because our Good Lord knows the teachers in the classroom aren't going to prod the little stinkers to THINK about what they are reading and the larger IMPLICATIONS. So go for it Mom! And GOOD FOR YOU!!!

 
At 8:01 PM , Blogger Unknown said...

It is sad at the end, right? Man, it has been a long time since I read that in 8th grade. I do however clearly remember Outsiders (mostly because Rob Lowe was in the movie).
I backseat teach too, but also voice to the teacher as well and my poor boy is only 9! (I sound like my mother, "What are they teaching you kids?")
Stay Gold Mimi, Stay Gold! :)

 
At 10:41 PM , Anonymous Anonymous said...

Is this the kid that reads the end first and skips around?
I can see why you would complain.

 
At 10:59 PM , Blogger Elizabeth @ The Garden Window said...

Mimi, if the teacher truly hadn`t discussed the title with them, she shouldn`t be teaching.......it is *such* a famous quotation to have as a title !!
You could write a mini-essay on the origin and significance of the tile, let alone the book :-)

 
At 1:29 AM , Blogger Meg said...

"It isn't on the *test*"?!?!?! Do they teach for *enrichment* anymore? (Foolish question, they weren't doing it when *my* kids were in school, and my youngest is 26!!)

I want to be fair and say, How many kids *care* about their lives' being enriched these days, but teaching has always been about casting pearls before little piglets, so that's no excuse.

I remember it as "plans," too.

 
At 11:22 AM , Blogger SuburbanMom said...

What a great mom you are!

(and I'm ashamed to admit I barely remember that book :(

 
At 8:27 AM , Blogger Stephanie said...

I loved that book. I think I've always said "plans", too. And I think you SHOULD ask him that about the ending of books--just to keep him on his toes. :)

 
At 1:26 PM , Blogger Mimi said...

Thank you everyone for your support. I don't feel so bad for being annoyed.

Simone - Stay Gold Mimi, Stay Gold! :) Thanks! That made me laugh.

Dawn - Is this the kid that reads the end first and skips around? Yep, that's him. I sure hope he didn't start with the end on this one.

Elizabeth - You could write a mini-essay on the origin and significance of the tile, let alone the book :-) I'm thinking you are supposed to write that mini-essay.

Nancy - my relatives in Scotland live right around the corner from "Robbie" Burns cottage and he is a long lost (down the line) relative! I'm not suprised to hear that! That's so cool!

Stephanie -
And I think you SHOULD ask him that about the ending of books
- Good point!

 
At 9:16 AM , Blogger Helena said...

"Wee, sleeket, cowrin, tim'rous beastie,
Oh, what a panic's in thy breastie!"

(poor little mousie!)

 

Post a Comment

Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]

<< Home